Overview
Our business strategy is to operate as a well-capitalized and profitable financial institution dedicated to providing exceptional personal service to our customers. Since being organized in 1938, we grew to become, at the time of our initial public offering of stock inApril 2007 , the nation's largest mutually-owned savings and loan association based on total assets. We credit our success to our continued emphasis on our primary values: "Love, Trust, Respect, and a Commitment to Excellence, along with Having Fun." Our values are reflected in the design and pricing of our loan and deposit products, as described below. Our values are further reflected in a long-term revitalization program encompassing the three-mile corridor of theBroadway-Slavic Village neighborhood inCleveland, Ohio where our main office was established and continues to be located and where the educational programs we have established and/or support are located. We intend to continue to adhere to our primary values and to support our customers and the communities in which we operate, as we pursue our mission to help people achieve the dream of home ownership and financial security while creating value for our shareholders, our customers, our communities and our associates. At September 30, 2021 2020 2019 2018 2017 (In thousands) Selected Financial Condition Data: Total assets$ 14,057,450 $
14 642 221
Cash and cash equivalents
488,326 498,033 275,143 269,775 268,218 Investment securities - available for sale 421,783 453,438 547,864 531,965 537,479 Loans held for sale 8,848 36,871 3,666 659 351 Loans, net 12,509,035 13,103,062 13,195,745 12,871,294 12,419,306 Bank owned life insurance 297,332 222,919 217,481 212,021 205,883 Prepaid expenses and other assets 91,586 104,832 87,957 44,344 61,086 Deposits 8,993,605 9,225,554 8,766,384 8,491,583 8,151,625 Borrowed funds 3,091,815 3,521,745 3,902,981 3,721,699 3,671,377 Shareholders' equity 1,732,280 1,671,853 1,696,754 1,758,404 1,689,959 54
————————————————– ——————————
Contents
For the past years
2021 2020 2019 2018 2017 (In thousands, except per share amounts) Selected Operating Data: Interest income$ 389,351 $ 455,298 $ 482,087 $ 443,045 $ 408,995 Interest expense 157,721 213,030 216,666 162,104 130,099 Net interest income 231,630 242,268 265,421 280,941 278,896 Provision (release) for credit losses on loans (9,000) 3,000 (10,000) (11,000) (17,000) Net interest income after provision (release) for credit losses on loans 240,630 239,268 275,421 291,941 295,896 Non-interest income 55,299 53,251 20,464 21,536 19,849 Non-interest expenses 195,835 192,274 193,673 192,313 182,404 Earnings before income tax 100,094 100,245 102,212 121,164 133,341 Income tax expense 19,087 16,928 21,975 35,757 44,464 Net earnings after income tax expense$ 81,007 $
83,317
Earnings per share Basic
$ 0.29 $
0.30
Diluted
$ 0.29 $
0.29
Cash dividends declared per share
$ 1.12 $
1.11
55
————————————————– ——————————
Contents
In or for the completed years
2021 2020 2019 2018 2017 Selected Financial Ratios and Other Data: Performance Ratios: Return on average assets 0.56 % 0.56 % 0.56 % 0.62 % 0.67 % Return on average equity 4.77 % 4.88 % 4.58 % 4.91 % 5.28 % Interest rate spread(1) 1.52 % 1.52 % 1.73 % 1.93 % 2.02 % Net interest margin(2) 1.66 % 1.69 % 1.92 % 2.08 % 2.16 % Efficiency ratio(3) 68.25 % 65.06 % 67.75 % 63.58 % 61.06 % Non-interest expense to average total assets 1.35 % 1.29 % 1.36 % 1.39 % 1.37 % Average interest-earning assets to average interest-bearing liabilities 111.92 % 111.41 % 112.28 % 112.96 % 113.29 %
Asset quality ratios:
Non-performing assets as a percent of total assets 0.32 % 0.37 % 0.50 % 0.57 % 0.62 % Non-accruing loans as a percent of total loans 0.35 % 0.41 % 0.54 % 0.60 % 0.63 % Allowance for credit losses on loans as a percent of non-accruing loans 145.96 % 87.95 % 54.60 % 54.56 % 61.89 % Allowance for credit losses on loans as a percent of total loans 0.51 % 0.36 % 0.29 % 0.33 % 0.39 % Capital Ratios: Association Total capital to risk-weighted assets(4) 21.00 % 19.96 % 19.56 % 20.47 % 21.37 % Tier 1 (leverage) capital to net average assets(4) 11.15 % 10.39 % 10.54 % 10.87 % 11.16 % Tier 1 capital to risk-weighted assets(4) 20.43 % 19.37 % 19.07 % 19.91 % 20.69 % Common equity tier 1 capital to risk-weighted assets(4) 20.43 % 19.37 % 19.07 % 19.91 % 20.69 %
Total capital to risk-weighted assets(4) 23.75 % 22.71 % 22.22 % 22.94 % 23.63 % Tier 1 (leverage) capital to net average assets(4) 12.65 % 11.88 % 12.05 % 12.25 % 12.41 % Tier 1 capital to risk-weighted assets(4) 23.18 % 22.13 % 21.73 % 22.39 % 22.96 % Common equity tier 1 capital to risk-weighted assets(4) 23.18 % 22.13 % 21.73 % 22.39 % 22.96 % Average equity to average total assets 11.72 % 11.50 % 12.30 % 12.56 % 12.67 % Other Data: Association: Number of full service offices 37 37 37 38 38 Loan production offices 7 7 8 8 8 ______________________ (1)Represents the difference between the weighted-average yield on interest-earning assets and the weighted-average cost of interest-bearing liabilities for the year. (2)The net interest margin represents net interest income as a percent of average interest-earning assets for the year. (3)The efficiency ratio represents non-interest expense divided by the sum of net interest income and non-interest income. (4)InApril 2020 , the Simplifications to the Capital Rule ("Rule") was adopted, which simplified certain aspects of the capital rule under Basel III. The impact of the Rule was not material to the regulatory capital ratios. COVID-19 Pandemic. During the current and previous fiscal years, the COVID-19 pandemic had a significant impact on our customers, associates and communities, which collectively impacts our shareholders. Our primary values and mission mentioned above have driven our responses related to COVID-19 and are summarized below. Customers •Branches are open and have returned to normal, operating business hours •ThroughSeptember 30, 2021 , over 2,200 customers, representing over$250 million of loans, have been helped by COVID-19 related forbearance plans 56 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Table of Contents •As a result of payoffs and customer resolutions, there were 149 customers, representing$21.8 million of loans, remaining in COVID-19 forbearance plans as ofSeptember 30, 2021 •Customer relief provided in the form of: forbearance plans available with multiple repayment options; waiving of late fees, overdraft fees and ATM fees •Expanded technology platforms, including mobile banking features and mobile deposit limits, as well as enhanced functionality for online deposit management Associates •Plans currently in place for associate hybrid (work from office/home options) •Safety precautions implemented as needed, including masks, germ shields and working distance requirements. •Provided a one-time after tax bonus of$1,500 to each associate •Medical benefit plan enhancements have been made to ensure COVID-19 coverage •An additional 10 days provided to associates for COVID-19 related absences •Over$100,000 added toRhonda's Kiss Associate Fund for family hardships Communities •Third Federal Foundation made a commitment to provide a$1.1 million lead gift to University Settlement to support a new$20 million development in the neighborhood near our headquarters that will provide 80 new units of affordable housing. •Hosted MetroHealth drive-through vaccinations for public and associates. •Leader in advocating for investment in Digital Equity by both investing to deploy devices and hot spots toSlavic Village families and participating on theGreater Cleveland Digital Equity Coalition . Shareholders •We are committed to paying an attractive dividend •Continued serving and lending to our customers in a responsible way •Strong credit quality and capital levels to support potential loan performance issues •Staying true to the Third Federal Values that have guided us throughout history (love, trust, respect, commitment to excellence, and fun) Beyond working through the challenges COVID-19 presents to the organization and society, management believes that the following matters are those most critical to our success: (1) controlling our interest rate risk exposure; (2) monitoring and limiting our credit risk; (3) maintaining access to adequate liquidity and diverse funding sources to support our growth; and (4) monitoring and controlling our operating expenses. Controlling Our Interest Rate Risk Exposure. Historically, our greatest risk has been our exposure to changes in interest rates. When we hold longer-term, fixed-rate assets, funded by liabilities with shorter-term re-pricing characteristics, we are exposed to potentially adverse impacts from changing interest rates, and most notably rising interest rates. Generally, and particularly over extended periods of time that encompass full economic cycles, interest rates associated with longer-term assets, like fixed-rate mortgages, have been higher than interest rates associated with shorter-term funding sources, like deposits. This difference has been an important component of our net interest income and is fundamental to our operations. We manage the risk of holding longer-term, fixed-rate mortgage assets primarily by maintaining regulatory capital in excess of levels required to be well capitalized, by promoting adjustable-rate loans and shorter-term fixed-rate loans, by marketing home equity lines of credit, which carry an adjustable rate of interest indexed to the prime rate, by opportunistically extending the duration of our funding sources and selectively selling a portion of our long-term, fixed-rate mortgage loans in the secondary market. The decision to extend the duration of some of our funding sources through interest rate swap contracts over the past few years has also caused additional interest rate risk exposure, as the current low market interest rates are lower than the rates in effect when some of the swap contracts were executed. This rate difference is reflected in the level of cash flow hedges included in accumulated other comprehensive loss. Levels ofRegulatory Capital AtSeptember 30, 2021 , the Company's Tier 1 (leverage) capital totaled$1.80 billion , or 12.65% of net average assets and 23.18% of risk-weighted assets, while the Association's Tier 1 (leverage) capital totaled$1.59 billion , or 11.15% of net average assets and 20.43% of risk-weighted assets. Each of these measures was more than twice the requirements currently in effect for the Association for designation as "well capitalized" under regulatory prompt corrective action provisions, which set minimum levels of 5.00% of net average assets and 8.00% of risk-weighted assets. Refer to the Liquidity and Capital Resources section of this Item 7 for additional discussion regarding regulatory capital requirements. Promotion of Adjustable-Rate Loans and Shorter-Term, Fixed-Rate Loans 57 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Table of Contents We market an adjustable-rate mortgage loan that provides us with improved interest rate risk characteristics when compared to a 30-year, fixed-rate mortgage loan. Our "Smart Rate" adjustable-rate mortgage offers borrowers an interest rate lower than that of a 30-year, fixed-rate loan. The interest rate of the Smart Rate mortgage is locked for three or five years then resets annually. The Smart Rate mortgage contains a feature to re-lock the rate an unlimited number of times at our then-current interest rate and fee schedule, for another three or five years (which must be the same as the original lock period) without having to complete a full refinance transaction. Re-lock eligibility is subject to a satisfactory payment performance history by the borrower (current at the time of re-lock, and no foreclosures or bankruptcies since the Smart Rate application was taken). In addition to a satisfactory payment history, re-lock eligibility requires that the property continues to be the borrower's primary residence. The loan term cannot be extended in connection with a re-lock nor can new funds be advanced. All interest rate caps and floors remain as originated. We also offer a ten-year, fully amortizing fixed-rate, first mortgage loan. The ten-year, fixed-rate loan has a more desirable interest rate risk profile when compared to loans with fixed-rate terms of 15 to 30 years and can help to more effectively manage interest rate risk exposure, yet provides our borrowers with the certainty of a fixed interest rate throughout the life of the obligation. The following tables set forth our first mortgage loan production and balances segregated by loan structure at origination.
For the past years
2021 2020 Amount Percent Amount Percent First Mortgage Loan Originations: (Dollars in thousands) ARM (all Smart Rate) production$ 1,089,410 30.0 %$ 1,223,422 39.7 %
Flat-rate production:
Terms less than or equal to 10 years 540,723 14.9 295,434 9.6 Terms greater than 10 years 1,997,694 55.1 1,558,942 50.7 Total fixed-rate production 2,538,417 70.0 1,854,376 60.3 Total First Mortgage Loan Originations:$ 3,627,827 100.0 %$ 3,077,798 100.0 % September 30, 2021 September 30, 2020 Amount Percent Amount Percent Balances of First Mortgage Loans Held For Investment: (Dollars in thousands) ARM (primarily Smart Rate) Loans$ 4,646,760 45.2 %$ 5,122,266 47.2 %
Fixed rate loans:
Terms less than or equal to 10 years 1,309,407 12.7 1,284,605 11.8 Terms greater than 10 years 4,322,931 42.1 4,443,140 41.0 Total fixed-rate loans 5,632,338 54.8 5,727,745 52.8
100.0 %$ 10,850,011 100.0 %
The following table shows the balances at
Current Balance of ARM Loans
Scheduled for
Interest Rate Reset During the Fiscal Years EndingSeptember 30 , (in thousands) 2022$277,640 2023 356,975 2024 500,226 2025 835,129 2026 2,177,133 2027 499,657 Total$4,646,760 58
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Table of Contents AtSeptember 30, 2021 andSeptember 30, 2020 , mortgage loans held for sale, all of which were long-term, fixed-rate first mortgage loans and all of which were held for sale to Fannie Mae, totaled$8.8 million and$36.9 million , respectively. 59 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Table of Contents Loan Portfolio Yield
The following tables show the interest balance and yield at the
September 30, 2021 Balance Percent Yield (Dollars in thousands) Total Loans: Fixed Rate
Terms less than or equal to 10 years
Terms greater than 10 years 4,322,931 34.4 % 3.56 % Total Fixed-Rate loans 5,632,338 44.8 % 3.39 % ARMs 4,646,760 36.9 % 2.79 %
Home Equity Loans and Lines of Credit 2,214,252
17.6% 2.51%
Construction and Other loans 83,315
0.7% 3.18%
Total Loans Receivable, net$ 12,576,665 100.0 % 3.01 % September 30, 2021 Fixed Rate Balance Balance Percent Yield (Dollars in thousands) Residential Mortgage Loans Ohio$ 5,664,887 $ 4,069,335 45.0 % 3.30 % Florida 1,841,114 774,166 14.6 % 3.08 % Other 2,773,097 788,837 22.1 % 2.76 % Total Residential Mortgage Loans 10,279,098 5,632,338 81.7 % 3.12 % Home Equity Loans and Lines of Credit Ohio 630,815 42,162 5.0 % 2.58 % Florida 438,212 28,998 3.5 % 2.52 % California 335,240 18,197 2.7 % 2.52 % Other 809,985 16,442 6.4 % 2.46 % Total Home Equity Loans and Lines of Credit 2,214,252 105,799 17.6 % 2.51 % Construction and Other loans 83,315 83,315 0.7 % 3.18 % Total Loans Receivable, net$ 12,576,665 $ 5,821,452 100.0 % 3.01 % Marketing Home Equity Lines of Credit We actively market home equity lines of credit, which carry an adjustable rate of interest indexed to the prime rate which provides interest rate sensitivity to that portion of our assets and is a meaningful strategy to manage our interest rate risk profile. AtSeptember 30, 2021 , the principal balance of home equity lines of credit totaled$1.97 billion . Our home equity lending is discussed in the preceding Lending Activities section of Item 1. Business in Part I.THIRD FEDERAL SAVINGS AND LOAN ASSOCIATION OF CLEVELAND . 60 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Table of Contents Extending the Duration of Funding Sources As a complement to our strategies to shorten the duration of our interest earning assets, as described above, we also seek to lengthen the duration of our interest bearing funding sources. These efforts include monitoring the relative costs of alternative funding sources such as retail deposits, brokered certificates of deposit, longer-term (e.g. four to six years) fixed rate advances from the FHLB ofCincinnati , and shorter-term (e.g. three months) advances from the FHLB ofCincinnati , the durations of which are extended by correlated interest rate exchange contracts. Each funding alternative is monitored and evaluated based on its effective interest payment rate, options exercisable by the creditor (early withdrawal, right to call, etc.), and collateral requirements. The interest payment rate is a function of market influences that are specific to the nuances and market competitiveness/breadth of each funding source. Generally, early withdrawal options are available to our retail CD customers but not to holders of brokered CDs; issuer call options are not provided on our advances from the FHLB ofCincinnati ; and we are not subject to early termination options with respect to our interest rate exchange contracts. Additionally, collateral pledges are not provided with respect to our retail CDs or our brokered CDs; but are required for our advances from the FHLB ofCincinnati as well as for our interest rate exchange contracts. As a result of increased available cash from loan sales beginning in fiscal 2020, as discussed below, we have also effectively extended the duration of funding sources by reducing the levels of our short-term and total funding. We will continue to evaluate the structure of our funding sources based on current needs. During the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 , the balance of deposits decreased$231.9 million , which was comprised of a$170.0 million decrease in the balance of customer retail deposits and a$61.9 million decrease in the balance of brokered CDs (which is inclusive of acquisition costs and subsequent amortization). During the year, we added$188.5 million of new brokered CDs with a weighted average interest rate of 0.37%, while brokered CDs of$250.4 million , with a weighted average interest rate of 1.98%, matured during the year. Additionally, during the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 , we decreased the balance of our total advances from the FHLB ofCincinnati by$429.9 million . We added$100.0 million of new, four- to five-year advances from the FHLB ofCincinnati with a weighted average interest rate of 0.90%; and we paid off at maturity,$525.0 million of advances with related interest rate swap contracts that had a weighted average interest rate of 1.19%. Other Interest Rate Risk Management Tools We also manage interest rate risk by selectively selling a portion of our long-term, fixed-rate mortgage loans in the secondary market. The sales of first mortgage loans have increased significantly during fiscal 2020 and fiscal 2021, due to an increase in the number of fixed-rate refinances. AtSeptember 30, 2021 , we serviced$2.26 billion of loans for others. In deciding whether to sell loans to manage interest rate risk, we also consider the level of gains to be recognized in comparison to the impact to our net interest income. We are planning on expanding our ability to sell certain fixed rate loans to Fannie Mae in fiscal 2022 and beyond, through the use of more traditional mortgage banking activities, including risk-based pricing and loan-level pricing adjustments. This concept will be tested in markets outside ofOhio andFlorida , and some additional startup and marketing costs will be incurred, but is not expected to significantly impact our financial results in fiscal 2022. We can also manage interest rate risk by selling non-Fannie Mae compliant mortgage loans to private investors, although those transactions are dependent upon favorable market conditions, including motivated private investors, and involve more complicated negotiations and longer settlement timelines. Loan sales are discussed later in this Part II, Item 7. under the heading Liquidity and Capital Resources, and in Part II, Item 7A. Quantitative and Qualitative Disclosures About Market Risk. Notwithstanding our efforts to manage interest rate risk, should a rapid and substantial increase occur in general market interest rates, or an extended period of a flat or inverted yield curve market persists, it is expected that, prospectively and particularly over a multi-year time horizon, the level of our net interest income would be adversely impacted. Monitoring and Limiting Our Credit Risk. While, historically, we had been successful in limiting our credit risk exposure by generally imposing high credit standards with respect to lending, the memory of the 2008 housing market collapse and financial crisis is a constant reminder to focus on credit risk. In response to the evolving economic landscape, we continuously revise and update our quarterly analysis and evaluation procedures, as needed, for each category of our lending with the objective of identifying and recognizing all appropriate credit losses. Continuous analysis and evaluation updates will be important as we monitor the impact to our borrowers as a result of the COVID-19 global pandemic. AtSeptember 30, 2021 , 89% of our assets consisted of residential real estate loans (both "held for sale" and "held for investment") and home equity loans and lines of credit, which were originated predominantly to borrowers inOhio andFlorida . Our analytic procedures and evaluations include specific reviews of all home equity loans and lines of credit that become 90 or more days past due, as well as specific reviews of all first mortgage loans that become 180 or more days past due. We transfer performing home equity lines of credit subordinate to first mortgages delinquent greater than 90 days to non-accrual status. Per the Interagency Statement on Loan Modifications and Reporting for Financial Institutions Working with Customers Affected by the Coronavirus, the COVID-19 related forbearance plans will not generally affect the delinquency status of the loan and therefore will not undergo a specific review unless extended greater than 12 months. We also charge-off performing loans to collateral value and classify 61 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Table of Contents those loans as non-accrual within 60 days of notification of all borrowers filing Chapter 7 bankruptcy, that have not reaffirmed or been dismissed, regardless of how long the loans have been performing. Loans where at least one borrower has been discharged of their obligation in Chapter 7 bankruptcy are classified as TDRs. AtSeptember 30, 2021 ,$14.7 million of loans in Chapter 7 bankruptcy status with no other modification to terms were included in total TDRs. AtSeptember 30, 2021 , the amortized cost in non-accrual status loans included$16.5 million of performing loans in Chapter 7 bankruptcy status, of which$16.1 million were also reported as TDRs. In an effort to limit our credit risk exposure and improve the credit performance of new customers, since 2009, we have tightened our credit eligibility criteria in evaluating a borrower's ability to successfully fulfill its repayment obligation, revised the design of many of our loan products to require higher borrower down-payments, limited the products available for condominiums and eliminated certain product features (such as interest-only and loans above certain LTV ratios). We use stringent, conservative lending standards for underwriting to reduce our credit risk. For first mortgage loans originated during the current fiscal year, the average credit score was 780, and the average LTV was 61%. The delinquency level related to loan originations prior to 2009, compared to originations in 2009 and after, reflect the higher credit standards to which we have subjected all new originations. As ofSeptember 30, 2021 , loans originated prior to 2009 had a balance of$445.8 million , of which$12.7 million , or 2.8%, were delinquent, while loans originated in 2009 and after had a balance of$12.1 billion , of which$13.2 million , or 0.1%, were delinquent. One aspect of our credit risk concern relates to high concentrations of our loans that are secured by residential real estate in specific states, particularlyOhio andFlorida , where a large portion of our historical lending has occurred. AtSeptember 30, 2021 , approximately 55.1% and 17.9% of the combined total of our residential Core and construction loans held for investment and approximately 28.6% and 19.8% of our home equity loans and lines of credit were secured by properties inOhio andFlorida , respectively. In an effort to moderate the concentration of our credit risk exposure in individual states, particularlyOhio andFlorida , we have utilized direct mail marketing, our internet site and our customer service call center to extend our lending activities to other attractive geographic locations. Currently, in addition toOhio andFlorida , we are actively lending in 23 other states and theDistrict of Columbia , and as a result of that activity, the concentration ratios of the combined total of our residential, Core and construction loans held for investment inOhio andFlorida have trended downward from theirSeptember 30, 2010 levels when the concentrations were 79.1% inOhio and 19.0% inFlorida . Of the total mortgage loan originations for the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 , 26.7% are secured by properties in states other thanOhio orFlorida . Our residential Home Today loans are another area of credit risk concern as the majority of these loans were originated under less stringent underwriting and credit standards than our Residential Core portfolio. Although we no longer originate loans under this program and the principal balance in these loans had declined to$63.8 million atSeptember 30, 2021 , and constituted only 0.6% of our total "held for investment" loan portfolio balance, they comprised 13.2% and 16.1% of our 90 days or greater delinquencies and our total delinquencies, respectively, at that date. AtSeptember 30, 2021 , approximately 95.4% and 4.5% of our residential Home Today loans were secured by properties inOhio andFlorida , respectively. AtSeptember 30, 2021 , the percentages of those loans delinquent 30 days or more inOhio andFlorida were 6.3% and 6.1%, respectively. We attempted to manage our Home Today credit risk by requiring private mortgage insurance for some loans. AtSeptember 30, 2021 , 10.5% of Home Today loans included private mortgage insurance coverage. From a peak amortized cost of$306.6 million atDecember 31, 2007 , the total amortized cost of the Home Today portfolio has declined to$63.4 million atSeptember 30, 2021 . Since the vast majority of Home Today loans were originated prior toMarch 2009 and we are no longer originating loans under our Home Today program, the Home Today portfolio will continue to decline in balance, primarily due to contractual amortization. As part of our adoption of CECL onOctober 1, 2020 , which includes a lifetime view of expected losses, our allowance for credit losses for the Home Today portfolio is reduced by expected future recoveries of loan amounts previously charged off. To supplant the Home Today product and to continue to meet the credit needs of our customers and the communities that we serve, we have offered Fannie Mae eligible, Home Ready loans since fiscal 2016. These loans are originated in accordance with Fannie Mae's underwriting standards. While we retain the servicing rights related to these loans, the loans, along with the credit risk associated therewith, are securitized and/or sold to Fannie Mae. Maintaining Access to Adequate Liquidity and Diverse Funding Sources to Support our Growth. For most insured depositories, customer and community confidence are critical to their ability to maintain access to adequate liquidity and to conduct business in an orderly manner. We believe that a well capitalized institution is one of the most important factors in nurturing customer and community confidence. Accordingly, we have managed the pace of our growth in a manner that reflects our emphasis on high capital levels. AtSeptember 30, 2021 , the Association's ratio of Tier 1 (leverage) capital to net average assets (a basic industry measure that deems 5.00% or above to represent a "well capitalized" status) was 11.15%. The Association's Tier 1 (leverage) capital ratio is higher atSeptember 30, 2021 than its ratio atSeptember 30, 2020 , which was 10.39%, due primarily to the combination of a reduction in total assets, plus net income at the Association offsetting the impact from a$55 million cash dividend payment that the Association made to the Company, its sole shareholder, inDecember 2020 that reduced the Association's Tier 1 (leverage) capital ratio by an estimated 36 basis points. Because of its intercompany 62 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Table of Contents nature, this dividend payment did not impact the Company's consolidated capital ratios which are reported in the Liquidity and Capital Resources section of this Item 7. We expect to continue to remain a well capitalized institution. In managing its level of liquidity, the Company monitors available funding sources, which include attracting new deposits (including brokered CDs), borrowing from others, the conversion of assets to cash and the generation of funds through profitable operations. The Company has traditionally relied on retail deposits as its primary means in meeting its funding needs. AtSeptember 30, 2021 , deposits totaled$8.99 billion (including$492.0 million of brokered CDs), while borrowings totaled$3.09 billion and borrowers' advances and servicing escrows totaled$151.1 million , combined. In evaluating funding sources, we consider many factors, including cost, collateral, duration and optionality, current availability, expected sustainability, impact on operations and capital levels. To attract deposits, we offer our customers attractive rates of return on our deposit products. Our deposit products typically offer rates that are highly competitive with the rates on similar products offered by other financial institutions. We intend to continue this practice, subject to market conditions. We preserve the availability of alternative funding sources through various mechanisms. First, by maintaining high capital levels, we retain the flexibility to increase our balance sheet size without jeopardizing our capital adequacy. Effectively, this permits us to increase the rates that we offer on our deposit products thereby attracting more potential customers. Second, we pledge available real estate mortgage loans and investment securities with the FHLB ofCincinnati and the FRB-Cleveland. AtSeptember 30, 2021 , these collateral pledge support arrangements provided the Association with the ability to borrow a maximum of$7.43 billion from the FHLB ofCincinnati and$245.7 million from the FRB-Cleveland Discount Window. Third, we have the ability to purchase overnight Fed Funds up to$360 million through various arrangements with other institutions. Fourth, we invest in high quality marketable securities that exhibit limited market price variability, and to the extent that they are not needed as collateral for borrowings, can be sold in the institutional market and converted to cash. AtSeptember 30, 2021 , our investment securities portfolio totaled$421.8 million . Finally, cash flows from operating activities have been a regular source of funds. During the fiscal years endedSeptember 30, 2021 and 2020, cash flows from operations totaled$83.2 million and$121.8 million , respectively. First mortgage loans (primarily fixed-rate, mortgage refinances with terms of 15 years or more and Home Ready) are originated under Fannie Mae procedures and are eligible for sale to Fannie Mae either as whole loans or within mortgage-backed securities. We expect that certain loan types (i.e. our Smart Rate adjustable-rate loans, home purchase fixed-rate loans and 10-year fixed-rate loans) will continue to be originated under our legacy procedures, which are not eligible for sale to Fannie Mae. For loans that are not originated under Fannie Mae procedures, the Association's ability to reduce interest rate risk via loan sales is limited to those loans that have established payment histories, strong borrower credit profiles and are supported by adequate collateral values that meet the requirements of the FHLB's Mortgage Purchase Program or of private third-party investors. AtSeptember 30, 2021 ,$8.8 million of agency eligible, long-term, fixed-rate first mortgage loans were classified as "held for sale." During the fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2021 ,$58.1 million of agency-compliant Home Ready loans and$704.2 million of long-term, fixed-rate, agency-compliant, non-Home Ready first mortgage loans were sold to Fannie Mae. Overall, while customer and community confidence can never be assured, the Company believes that our liquidity is adequate and that we have adequate access to alternative funding sources. Monitoring and Controlling Operating Expenses. We continue to focus on managing operating expenses. Our ratio of non-interest expense to average assets was 1.35% for the fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2021 and 1.29% for the fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2020 . The decrease in average assets during the current fiscal year contributed to the increase in the ratio. As ofSeptember 30, 2021 , our average assets per full-time associate and our average deposits per full-time associate were$14.1 million and$9.0 million , respectively. We believe that each of these measures compares favorably with industry averages. Our relatively high average deposits (exclusive of brokered CDs) held at our branch offices ($229.8 million per branch office as ofSeptember 30, 2021 ) contributes to our expense management efforts by limiting the overhead costs of serving our customers. We will continue our efforts to control operating expenses as we grow our business. Critical Accounting Policies Critical accounting policies are defined as those that involve significant judgments and uncertainties, and could potentially give rise to materially different results under different assumptions and conditions. We believe that the most critical accounting policies upon which our financial condition and results of operations depend, and which involve the most complex subjective decisions or assessments, are our policies with respect to our allowance for credit losses, income taxes and pension benefits. Allowance for Credit Losses. The allowance for credit losses is the amount estimated by management as necessary to absorb credit losses related to both the loan portfolio and off-balance sheet commitments based on a life of loan methodology. 63 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Table of Contents The amount of the allowance is based on significant estimates and the ultimate losses may vary from such estimates as more information becomes available or conditions change. The methodology for determining the allowance for credit losses is considered a critical accounting policy by management due to the high degree of judgment involved, the subjectivity of the assumptions used and the potential for changes in the economic environment that could result in changes to the amount of the recorded allowance for credit losses. AtSeptember 30, 2021 , the allowance for credit losses was$89.3 million or 0.71% of total loans. An increase or decrease of 10% in the allowance atSeptember 30, 2021 would result in a$8.9 million charge or release, respectively, to income before income taxes. As a substantial percentage of our loan portfolio is collateralized by real estate, appraisals of the underlying value of property securing loans are critical in determining the charge-offs for specific loans. Assumptions are instrumental in determining the value of properties. Overly optimistic assumptions or negative changes to assumptions could significantly affect the valuation of a property securing a loan and the related allowance determined. Management carefully reviews the assumptions supporting such appraisals to determine that the resulting values reasonably reflect amounts realizable on the related loans. Management performs a quarterly evaluation of the adequacy of the allowance for credit losses. We consider a variety of factors in establishing this estimate including, but not limited to, current economic conditions, including the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic, delinquency statistics, geographic concentrations, economic forecasts and how they correlate to management's view of the future, the adequacy of the underlying collateral, the financial strength of the borrower, results of internal loan reviews and other relevant factors. This evaluation is inherently subjective as it requires material estimates by management that may be susceptible to significant change based on changes in economic and real estate market conditions. The evaluation is comprised of a specific component and a general component. The specific component relates to loans that are delinquent or otherwise identified as a problem loan through the application of our loan review process and our loan grading system. All such loans are evaluated individually, with principal consideration given to the value of the collateral securing the loan or cash flow analysis. The general component of the evaluation is determined by applying economic forecasts and historical averages to the remaining loans and off-balance sheet commitments analyzed by portfolio and risk characteristics. Quantitative estimated losses are supplemented by more qualitative factors that impact potential losses. Qualitative factors include economic forecasts, various market conditions, such as collateral values and unemployment rates and future recoveries not estimated in the models. We analyze historical loss experience, delinquency trends, general economic conditions and geographic concentrations. These analyses establish credit loss estimates to determine the amount of the general component of the allowance. Refer to the Lending Activities section of Item 1. Business in Part I. for further discussion. Actual loan losses may be significantly more than the allowances we have established, which would have a materially adverse effect on our financial results. Income Taxes. We consider accounting for income taxes a critical accounting policy due to the subjective nature of certain estimates that are involved in the calculation. We use the asset/liability method of accounting for income taxes in which deferred tax assets and liabilities are established for the temporary differences between the financial reporting basis and the tax basis of our assets and liabilities. We must assess the realization of the deferred tax asset and, to the extent that we believe that recovery is not likely, a valuation allowance is established. Adjustments to increase or decrease existing valuation allowances, if any, are charged or credited, respectively, to income tax expense. AtSeptember 30, 2021 , no valuation allowances were outstanding. Even though we have determined a valuation allowance is not required for deferred tax assets atSeptember 30, 2021 , there is no guarantee that those assets will be recognizable in the future. Pension Benefits. The determination of our obligations and expense for pension benefits is dependent upon certain assumptions used in calculating such amounts. Key assumptions used in the actuarial valuations include the discount rate and expected long-term rate of return on plan assets. Actual results could differ from the assumptions and market driven rates may fluctuate. Significant differences in actual experience or significant changes in the assumptions could materially affect future pension obligations and expense. Comparison of Financial Condition atSeptember 30, 2021 andSeptember 30, 2020 Total assets decreased$584.8 million , or 4%, to$14.06 billion atSeptember 30, 2021 from$14.64 billion atSeptember 30, 2020 . This decrease was mainly due to the combination of loan sales and principal repayments on loans exceeding the total of new loan originations and the impact of adopting CECL, partially offset by an increase in bank owned life insurance contracts. Cash and cash equivalents decreased$9.7 million , or 2%, to$488.3 million atSeptember 30, 2021 from$498.0 million atSeptember 30, 2020 . This decrease was the result of cash flows from maturing investment securities and loan sales in the secondary market, which were used to retire maturing liabilities or reinvested in investment securities and/or loan products that 64 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Table of Contents provide market yields. We manage cash to maintain the level of liquidity described later in the Liquidity and Capital Resources section of the Overview. Investment securities, all of which are classified as available for sale, decreased$31.6 million , or 7%, to$421.8 million atSeptember 30, 2021 from$453.4 million atSeptember 30, 2020 . Investment securities decreased as the combined effect of$317.1 million in principal paydowns and$7.2 million of net acquisition premium amortization that occurred in the mortgage-backed securities portfolio exceeded the combined effect of$297.5 million in purchases and an$4.8 million reduction of unrealized losses during the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 . There were no sales of investment securities during the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 . Loans held for investment, net, decreased$594.0 million , or 5%, to$12.51 billion atSeptember 30, 2021 from$13.10 billion atSeptember 30, 2020 . Residential mortgage loans decreased$570.9 million , or 5%, to$10.28 billion atSeptember 30, 2021 . In addition, there was an$18.0 million decrease in the balance of home equity loans and lines of credit during the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 , as repayments exceeded new originations and additional draws on existing accounts. Also contributing to the contraction in loans held for investment during the fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2021 were profitable loan sales of$762.3 million , which effectively reduced asset growth during the fiscal year. During the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 ,$1.09 billion of three- and five-year "SmartRate" loans were originated while$2.54 billion of 10-, 15-, and 30-year fixed-rate first mortgage loans were originated. BetweenSeptember 30, 2020 andSeptember 30, 2021 , the total fixed-rate portion of the first mortgage loan portfolio decreased$95.4 million , or 2%, and was comprised of a decrease of$120.2 million in the balance of fixed-rate loans with original terms greater than 10 years, partially offset by an increase of$24.8 million in the balance of fixed-rate loans with original terms of 10 years or less. Of the total$3.63 billion in first mortgage loan originations for the fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2021 , 73% were refinance transactions and 27% were purchases, 30% were adjustable-rate mortgages and 70% were fixed-rate mortgages. Fixed rate mortgages with terms of 10 years or less accounted for 15% of total first mortgage loan originations. During the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 , we completed$762.3 million in loan sales, which included$58.1 million of agency-compliant Home Ready loans and$704.2 million of other long-term, fixed-rate, agency-compliant, first mortgage loans that were sold to Fannie Mae. Also, during the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 , we purchased long-term, fixed-rate first mortgage loans that had a remaining balance of$43.0 million atSeptember 30, 2021 . Commitments originated for home equity lines of credit and equity and bridge loans were$1.74 billion for the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 compared to$1.32 billion for the year endedSeptember 30, 2020 . AtSeptember 30, 2021 , pending commitments to originate new home equity lines of credit were$301.4 million and equity and bridge loans were$168.9 million . Refer to the Controlling Our Interest Rate Risk Exposure section of the Overview for additional information. The total allowance for credit losses was$89.3 million , or 0.71% of total loans receivable, atSeptember 30, 2021 , and included a$25.0 million liability for unfunded commitments. AtSeptember 30, 2020 , the allowance for credit losses was$46.9 million , or 0.36% of total loans receivable and there was no liability for unfunded commitments. OnOctober 1, 2020 , the Company adopted the Current Expected Credit Loss methodology and recognized a$46.2 million increase to the allowance for credit losses and a related$35.8 million reduction to retained earnings, net of tax. During the fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2021 , a$9.0 million release of provision from the allowance for credit losses was recognized compared to a provision of$3.0 million for the prior fiscal year. Releases from the allowance for credit losses during the recent fiscal year were primarily due to recoveries exceeding charge-offs and improvements in the economic trends and forecasts used to estimate credit losses for the reasonable and supportable period under CECL. As a result of loan recoveries exceeding charge-offs, the Company recorded$5.2 million of net loan recoveries for the fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2021 , compared to$5.0 million of net loan recoveries for the fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2020 . While actual loan charge-offs and delinquencies remained low atSeptember 30, 2021 , some borrowers have experienced unemployment or reduced income as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic. We continue to monitor the performance of forbearance plans offered to our customer as a result of the pandemic; however, most borrowers have since exited their plan or reached a resolution. ThroughSeptember 30, 2021 , there were 2,204 customers, representing over$250 million of loans, who were helped by a COVID-19 forbearance plan. As a result of payoffs and customer resolutions, there were 149 customers, representing$21.8 million of loans, or 0.17 % of total loans, remaining in COVID-19 forbearance plans as ofSeptember 30, 2021 . Refer to Note 5. LOANS AND ALLOWANCE FOR CREDIT LOSSES of the NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS for additional discussion. The amount of FHLB stock owned increased$26.0 million , or 19.01%, to$162.8 million atSeptember 30, 2021 from$136.8 million atSeptember 30, 2020 . FHLB stock ownership requirements dictate the amount of stock owned at any given time. Total bank owned life insurance contracts increased$74.4 million , to$297.3 million atSeptember 30, 2021 , from$222.9 million atSeptember 30, 2020 , primarily due to$70 million of additional premiums placed during the current fiscal year. 65 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Table of Contents Deposits decreased$231.9 million , or 3%, to$8.99 billion atSeptember 30, 2021 from$9.23 billion atSeptember 30, 2020 . The decrease in deposits resulted primarily from a$567.5 million decrease in CDs, partially offset by a$196.7 million increase in our savings accounts (consisting of a$43.5 million increase in money market accounts in the state ofFlorida and a$157.1 million increase in our higher yield savings accounts), and a$136.2 million increase in our interest-bearing checking accounts. While the current interest rate environment is extremely low, we believe that our savings and checking accounts provide a stable source of funds. In addition, our savings accounts are expected to reprice in a manner similar to our home equity lending products, and, therefore, assist us in managing interest rate risk. The balance of brokered CDs atSeptember 30, 2021 was$492.0 million , a decrease of$61.9 million , from the balance of$553.9 million atSeptember 30, 2020 . Borrowed funds, all from the FHLB ofCincinnati , decreased$429.9 million , or 12%, to$3.09 billion atSeptember 30, 2021 from$3.52 billion atSeptember 30, 2020 . Included in the decrease were$525.0 million of 90 day advances that were utilized for longer term interest rate swap contracts that matured during the year and were paid off from available cash, partially offset by a$95.1 million net increase in long term advances. There were no overnight or other short-term advances atSeptember 30, 2021 or atSeptember 30, 2020 . The total balance of borrowed funds of$3.09 billion atSeptember 30, 2021 consisted of long-term advances of$640.4 million with a remaining weighted average maturity of approximately 3.0 years and short-term advances of$2.45 billion aligned with interest rate swap contracts with a remaining weighted average effective maturity of 2.1 years. Interest rate swaps have been used to extend the duration of short-term borrowings to approximately four to seven years at inception, by paying a fixed rate of interest and receiving the variable rate. Refer to the Extending the Duration of Funding Sources section of the Overview and Part II, Item 7A. Quantitative and Qualitative Disclosures About Market Risk for additional discussion regarding short-term borrowings and interest-rate swaps. Accrued expenses and other liabilities increased$23.0 million to$88.6 million atSeptember 30, 2021 , from$65.6 million atSeptember 30, 2020 . The increase is primarily due to a$25.0 million liability for unfunded commitments, created as a result of the implementation of CECL during the current year. Total shareholders' equity increased$60.4 million , or 4%, to$1.73 billion atSeptember 30, 2021 from$1.67 billion atSeptember 30, 2020 . Activity reflects the positive impacts from$81.0 million of net income, a$64.2 million decrease in accumulated other comprehensive loss and$8.1 million of positive adjustments related to our stock compensation and employee stock ownership plans, reduced by$57.1 million of quarterly dividend payments and a$35.8 million , net of tax reduction related to the increase to the allowance for credit losses with the adoption of CECL. The decrease in accumulated other comprehensive loss is primarily a result of changes in market interest rates related to our interest rate swap contracts, and from actuarial improvements related to our defined benefit plan. No shares of our common stock were repurchased during the fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2021 . As a result of theJuly 13, 2021 andJuly 14, 2020 mutual member votes, Third Federal Savings, MHC, the mutual holding company that owns approximately 81% of the outstanding stock of the Company, was able to waive receipt of its share of each dividend paid. Refer to Item 5. Market for Registrant's Common Equity, Related Stockholder Matters and Issuer Purchases ofEquity Securities for additional details regarding the repurchase of shares of common stock and the payment of dividends. 66 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Table of Contents Analysis of Net Interest Income Net interest income represents the difference between the income we earn on our interest-earning assets and the expense we pay on our interest-bearing liabilities. Net interest income depends on the volume of interest-earning assets and interest-bearing liabilities and the rates earned on such assets and the rates paid on such liabilities. Average balances and yields. The following table sets forth average balances, average yields and costs, and certain other information at and for the fiscal years indicated. No tax-equivalent yield adjustments were made, as the effect thereof were not material. Average balances are derived from daily average balances. Non-accrual loans are included in the computation of average balances, but only cash payments received on those loans during the period presented are reflected in the yield. The yields set forth below include the effect of deferred fees, deferred expenses, discounts and premiums that are amortized or accreted to interest income or interest expense. For the Fiscal Years Ended September 30, 2021 2020 2019 Interest Interest Interest Average Income/ Yield/ Average Income/ Yield/ Average Income/ Yield/ Balance Expense Cost Balance Expense Cost Balance Expense Cost (Dollars in thousands)
Interest-bearing assets:
Interest-earning cash equivalents$ 567,035 $ 673 0.12%$ 307,902 $ 1,909 0.62 %$ 220,458 $ 4,998 2.27 % Investment securities - - -% - - - % 3,308 79 2.39 % Mortgage-backed securities 428,590 3,822 0.89% 527,195 9,707 1.84 % 555,076 13,021 2.35 % Loans(1) 12,800,542 381,887 2.98% 13,366,447 440,697 3.30 % 12,938,824 458,779 3.55 %Federal Home Loan Bank stock 155,322 2,969 1.91% 120,011 2,985 2.49 % 96,712 5,210 5.39 % Total interest-earning assets 13,951,489 389,351 2.79% 14,321,555 455,298 3.18 % 13,814,378 482,087 3.49 % Non-interest-earning assets 532,786 540,421 422,738 Total assets$ 14,484,275 $ 14,861,976 $ 14,237,116
Interest-bearing debts:
Checking accounts$ 1,079,699 1,140 0.11%$ 917,552 1,477 0.16 %$ 881,233 3,188 0.36 % Savings accounts 1,742,042 2,992 0.17% 1,530,977 7,775 0.51 % 1,381,646 11,676 0.85 % Certificates of deposit 6,339,412 93,187 1.47% 6,621,289 130,990 1.98 % 6,388,905 128,489 2.01 % Borrowed funds 3,303,925 60,402 1.83% 3,785,026 72,788 1.92 % 3,651,273 73,313 2.01 % Total interest-bearing liabilities 12,465,078 157,721 1.27% 12,854,844 213,030 1.66 % 12,303,057 216,666 1.76 % Non-interest-bearing liabilities 321,958 298,520 182,598 Total liabilities 12,787,036 13,153,364 12,485,655 Shareholders' equity 1,697,239 1,708,612 1,751,461 Total liabilities and shareholders' equity$ 14,484,275 $ 14,861,976 $ 14,237,116 Net interest income$ 231,630 $ 242,268 $ 265,421 Interest rate spread(2) 1.52 % 1.52 % 1.73 % Net interest-earning assets(3)$ 1,486,411 $ 1,466,711 $ 1,511,321 Net interest margin(4) 1.66 % 1.69 % 1.92 %
Average interest-bearing assets at
average interest-bearing liabilities 111.92 % 111.41 % 112.28 % (1) Loans include both mortgage loans held for sale and loans held for investment. (2)Interest rate spread represents the difference between the yield on average interest-earning assets and the cost of average interest-bearing liabilities. (3)Net interest-earning assets represent total interest-earning assets less total interest-bearing liabilities. (4)Net interest margin represents net interest income divided by total interest-earning assets. 67 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Table of Contents Rate/Volume Analysis. The following table presents the effects of changing rates (yields) and volumes (average balances) on our net interest income for the fiscal years indicated. The rate column shows the effects attributable to changes in rate (changes in rate multiplied by prior volume). The volume column shows the effects attributable to changes in volume (changes in volume multiplied by prior rate). The net column represents the sum of the prior columns. For purposes of this table, changes attributable to both rate and volume, which cannot be segregated, have been allocated proportionately, based on the changes due to rate and the changes due to volume. For the Fiscal Years Ended September 30, 2021 vs. For the Fiscal Years Ended September 30, 2020 vs. 2020 2019 Increase (Decrease) Increase (Decrease) Due to Due to Volume Rate Net Volume Rate Net (In thousands)
Interest-bearing assets:
Interest-earning cash equivalents$ 944 $ (2,180) $ (1,236) $ 3,714 $ (6,803) $ (3,089) Investment securities - - - (79) - (79) Mortgage-backed securities (1,566) (4,319) (5,885) (627) (2,687) (3,314) Loans (18,112) (40,698) (58,810) 16,110 (34,192) (18,082) Federal Home Loan Bank stock 764 (780) (16) 1,802 (4,027) (2,225) Total interest-earning assets (17,970) (47,977) (65,947) 20,920 (47,709) (26,789) Interest-bearing liabilities: Checking accounts 356 (693) (337) 137 (1,848) (1,711) Savings accounts 1,259 (6,042) (4,783) 1,449 (5,350) (3,901) Certificates of deposit (5,373) (32,430) (37,803) 4,535 (2,034) 2,501 Borrowed funds (8,923) (3,463) (12,386) 3,426 (3,951) (525) Total interest-bearing liabilities (12,681) (42,628) (55,309) 9,547 (13,183)
(3,636)
Net change in net interest income$ (5,289) $
(5.349)
Comparison of operating results for the years ended
and 2020
General. Net income decreased$2.3 million to$81.0 million for the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 compared to$83.3 million for the year endedSeptember 30, 2020 . A decline in net interest income and an increase in non-interest expense for the current fiscal year offset the benefit of an increase in non-interest income and releases from the credit loss provision. Interest and Dividend Income. Interest and dividend income decreased$65.9 million , or 14%, to$389.4 million during the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 compared to$455.3 million during the prior year. The decrease in interest and dividend income resulted primarily from a decrease in interest income from loans, and to a lesser extent, interest income on mortgage-backed securities and interest earning cash equivalents. Lower market interest rates impacted each category, as well as lower average balances for loans and mortgage backed securities. Interest income on loans decreased$58.8 million , or 13%, to$381.9 million for the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 compared to$440.7 million for the year endedSeptember 30, 2020 . This decrease was attributed to a 32 basis point decrease in the average yield on loans to 2.98% for the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 from 3.30% for the prior year. Also contributing to the decline in average yield was a$565.9 million decrease in the average balance of loans to$12.80 billion for the current year compared to$13.37 billion during the prior year. The decrease in interest income between fiscal periods is due to lower yields on loans as many borrowers refinanced to take advantage of the lower rate environment and a decrease in the average balance of loans due to loan sales and payoffs. Interest income on mortgage-backed securities decreased$5.9 million , or 61%, to$3.8 million during the current year compared to$9.7 million during the year endedSeptember 30, 2020 . This decrease was attributed to a 95 basis point decrease in the average yield on mortgage-backed securities, combined with a$98.6 million decrease in the average balance of mortgage-backed securities to$428.6 million for the current year compared to$527.2 million during the prior year due to prepayments. During the fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2021 prepayment speeds of mortgage-backed securities were elevated due to the low interest rate environment, which reduced the principal balance of loans included in some of the mortgage-backed securities pools and hence the interest income generated from those bonds. Generally low interest rates also contributed to the 68 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Table of Contents challenging investment environment as bond purchases during the fiscal year had lower coupon yields compared to the bonds that matured during the fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2021 . Interest Expense. Interest expense decreased$55.3 million , or 26%, to$157.7 million during the current year compared to$213.0 million during the year endedSeptember 30, 2020 . The decrease resulted from decreases in interest expense on both deposits and borrowed funds. Lower market interest rates impacted each category, as well as lower average balances for total interest-bearing liabilities. Interest expense on CDs decreased$37.8 million , or 29%, to$93.2 million during the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 compared to$131.0 million during the year endedSeptember 30, 2020 . The decrease was attributed primarily to a 51 basis point decrease in the average rate we paid on CDs to 1.47% during the current year from 1.98% during the prior year. Additionally, there was a$281.9 million , or 4%, decrease in the average balance of CDs to$6.34 billion from$6.62 billion during the prior year. Interest expense on savings and checking accounts decreased$4.8 million and$0.4 million , respectively, to$3.0 million and$1.1 million during the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 , compared to the prior year due to a decrease in the average rates we paid on the deposits. Rates were adjusted on deposits in response to changes in general market rates as well as to changes in the rates paid by our competition. Interest expense on borrowed funds, all from the FHLB ofCincinnati , as impacted by related interest rate swap contracts, decreased$12.4 million , or 17%, to$60.4 million during the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 from$72.8 million during the year endedSeptember 30, 2020 . The decrease was attributed to a combination of a$481.1 million , or 13%, decrease in the average balance of borrowed funds to$3.30 billion during the current year from$3.78 billion during the prior year, as well as a nine basis point decrease in the average rate paid for these funds to 1.83% during the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 from 1.92% for the year endedSeptember 30, 2020 . The balance decrease during the year resulted from available cash used to pay-off advances related to longer term interest rate swap contracts that matured during the year. Also impacting the prior year comparison was$7.8 million of additional interest expense that was recognized during the year endedSeptember 30, 2020 , as a result of the early termination inSeptember 2020 of$100 million of interest rate swap contracts related to the prepayment of FHLB ofCincinnati advances. Refer to the Extending the Duration of Funding Sources section of the Overview and Comparison of Financial Condition for further discussion. Net Interest Income. Net interest income decreased$10.7 million , or 4%, to$231.6 million during the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 from$242.3 million during the year endedSeptember 30, 2020 . The decrease between fiscal years was primarily due to the lower average interest-earning asset balances, as while our percentage yield declined, our interest rate spread remained the same between the two years. We experienced lower yields on loans as many borrowers refinanced to take advantage of the lower rate environment and a decrease in the average balances of loans due to loan sales and payoffs. In addition, the increase in lower yielding cash equivalent investments was a detriment to the overall yield on assets. Funding costs also declined, partially offsetting the decrease in interest income, but slower repricing of longer term CDs and interest rate swap contracts, slowed the decline. Funding cost decreased through a reduction in the average balance of borrowed funds, including maturities and prior year terminations of FHLB advances and their related swap contracts; the repricing of certificates of deposit as they mature, to market rates of interest; and a heightened migration to lower-priced non-maturity deposit accounts from certificates of deposit due to historically low yield differentials. Average interest-earning assets decreased during the current year by$370.1 million , or 3%, when compared to the year endedSeptember 30, 2020 . The decrease in average interest-earning assets was attributed primarily due to the reduction in the average balance of our loan portfolio and to a lesser extent the mortgage back securities portfolio. Average interest-bearing liabilities decreased by$389.7 million . The average yield on interest earning assets decreased 39 basis points to 2.79% from 3.18%, compared to a 39 basis point decrease in the average rate paid on interest-bearing liabilities to 1.27% in the current period from 1.66% in the prior period. The interest rate spread was 1.52% for both the fiscal years endedSeptember 30, 2021 andSeptember 30, 2020 . The net interest margin was 1.66% for the fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2021 and 1.69% for the fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2020 . Provision (Release) for Credit Losses. We recorded a release from the allowance for credit losses of$9.0 million during the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 and a$3.0 million provision for loan losses during the year endedSeptember 30, 2020 . Releases from the allowance for credit losses during the recent fiscal year were primarily due to recoveries exceeding charge-offs and improvements in the economic trends and forecasts used to estimate credit losses for the reasonable and supportable period, under the CECL methodology adopted effectiveOctober 1, 2020 . As delinquencies in the portfolio are resolved through pay-off, short sale or foreclosure, or management determines the collateral is not sufficient to satisfy the loan, uncollected balances have been charged against the allowance for credit losses previously provided. When amounts previously charged off are subsequently collected, the recoveries are added to the allowance. Future recoveries may continue if housing market conditions stay strong and payment performance on previously charged-off loans continues. For the fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2021 , we recorded net recoveries of$5.2 million , as compared to net recoveries of$5.0 million for the year endedSeptember 30, 2020 . The allowance for credit losses, including a$25.0 million liability for unfunded commitments under 69 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Table of Contents CECL, was$89.3 million , or 0.71% of the total amortized cost in loans receivable, atSeptember 30, 2021 . AtSeptember 30, 2020 , the allowance was$46.9 million , or 0.36% of the total amortized cost in loans receivable and there was no liability for unfunded commitments. Balances of amortized costs are net of deferred fees, expenses and any applicable loans-in-process. AtSeptember 30, 2021 and 2020, we believe we had recorded an allowance for credit losses that provides for all losses that are both probable and reasonable to estimate atSeptember 30, 2021 and 2020, respectively; this includes consideration for the difference in methodology to record provisions for credit losses for each of the respective time periods. During and for the fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2021 the CECL methodology was followed to determine the appropriate balance for the allowance for credit losses while the incurred loss methodology was followed in the prior and previous fiscal years. Refer to the Lending Activities section of the Overview and Note 5. LOANS AND ALLOWANCE FOR CREDIT LOSSES of the NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS for further discussion. Non-Interest Income. Non-interest income increased$2.0 million , or 4%, to$55.3 million during the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 compared to$53.3 million during the year endedSeptember 30, 2020 . The increase in non-interest income was primarily due to an increase in the net gain on sale of loans, which was$33.1 million during the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 , compared to$28.4 million during the year endedSeptember 30, 2020 . There were loan sales, including commitments to sell, of$762.3 million during the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 , compared to loan sales of$844.3 million during the year endedSeptember 30, 2020 . In addition to the increase in the net gain on the sale of loans, there was also an increase in the cash surrender value and death benefits on bank owned life insurance contracts. For the fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2021 , bank owned life insurance contracts increased by$74.4 million to$297.3 million , primarily due to$70 million of additional premiums placed during the fiscal year. These increases were offset by a decrease in other non-interest income which, in the previous fiscal year, included$4.7 million of net gain on the sale of commercial property. Non-Interest Expense. Non-interest expense increased$3.5 million , or 2%, to$195.8 million during the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 compared to$192.3 million during the year endedSeptember 30, 2020 . This increase resulted primarily from increases in salary and employee benefits as well as marketing expenses, partially offset by a decrease in other expenses. The increase in salary and employee benefits was spread between associate compensation, group health insurance, stock benefit plan expense, and a one-time$1,500 after-tax bonus paid to each associate during the first quarter of fiscal year 2021 in recognition of special efforts made during the pandemic crisis. The increase in marketing expense was timing related, as some marketing efforts were delayed during the previous fiscal year, in response to COVID-19. Other expenses decreased as a result of the non recurrence of$1.1 million of early termination fees incurred last year related to the prepayment of FHLB ofCincinnati advances and a$1.8 million reduction in pension related expenses this year due to actuarial valuation improvements. Income Tax Expense. The provision for income taxes was$19.1 million during the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 compared to$16.9 million during the year endedSeptember 30, 2020 . The change was a result of a lower prior year provision, which included a carry back of net tax operating losses to years taxed at higher rates, resulting in a prior fiscal year tax benefit of$3.6 million . The provision for the current year included$17.5 million of federal income tax provision and$1.6 million of state income tax provision. The provision for the year endedSeptember 30, 2020 included$15.2 million of federal income tax provision and$1.7 million of state income tax provision. Our effective federal tax rate was 17.8% during the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 and 15.5% during the year endedSeptember 30, 2020 . For a comparison of operating results for the fiscal years endedSeptember 30, 2020 and 2019, see the Company's Form 10-K for the fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2020 . Liquidity and Capital Resources Liquidity is the ability to meet current and future financial obligations of a short-term nature. Our primary sources of funds consist of deposit inflows, loan repayments, advances from the FHLB ofCincinnati , borrowings from the FRB-Cleveland Discount Window, overnight Fed Funds through various arrangements with other institutions, proceeds from brokered CDs transactions, principal repayments and maturities of securities, and sales of loans. In addition to the primary sources of funds described above, we have the ability to obtain funds through the use of collateralized borrowings in the wholesale markets, and from sales of securities. Also, debt issuance by the Company and access to the equity capital markets via a supplemental minority stock offering or a full conversion (second-step) transaction remain as other potential sources of liquidity, although these channels generally require up to nine months of lead time. While maturities and scheduled amortization of loans and securities are predictable sources of funds, deposit flows and mortgage prepayments are greatly influenced by interest rates, economic conditions and competition. The Association's Asset/Liability Management Committee is responsible for establishing and monitoring our liquidity targets and strategies in order to 70 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Table of Contents ensure that sufficient liquidity exists for meeting the borrowing needs and deposit withdrawals of our customers as well as unanticipated contingencies. We generally seek to maintain a minimum liquidity ratio of 5% (which we compute as the sum of cash and cash equivalents plus unencumbered investment securities for which ready markets exist, divided by total assets). For the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 , our liquidity ratio averaged 6.66%. We believe that we had sufficient sources of liquidity to satisfy our short- and long-term liquidity needs as ofSeptember 30, 2021 . We regularly adjust our investments in liquid assets based upon our assessment of expected loan demand, expected deposit flows, yields available on interest-earning deposits and securities, scheduled liability maturities and the objectives of our asset/liability management program. Excess liquid assets are generally invested in interest-earning deposits and short- and intermediate-term securities. Our most liquid assets are cash and cash equivalents. The levels of these assets are dependent on our operating, financing, lending and investing activities during any given period. AtSeptember 30, 2021 , cash and cash equivalents totaled$488.3 million which represented a decrease of 2% fromSeptember 30, 2020 . Investment securities classified as available for sale, which provide additional sources of liquidity, totaled$421.8 million atSeptember 30, 2021 . During the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 , loan sales, including commitments to sell, totaled$762.3 million , which included sales to Fannie Mae consisting of$704.2 million of long-term, fixed-rate, agency-compliant, non-Home Ready first mortgage loans and$58.1 million of loans that qualified under Fannie Mae's Home Ready initiative. Loans originated under Home Ready initiatives are classified as "held for sale" at origination. Loans originated under non-Home Ready, Fannie Mae compliant procedures are classified as "held for investment" until they are specifically identified for sale. AtSeptember 30, 2021 ,$8.8 million of long-term, fixed-rate residential first mortgage loans were classified as "held for sale," under Fannie Mae's Home Ready initiative. Our cash flows are derived from operating activities, investing activities and financing activities as reported in our CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF CASH FLOWS included in the CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS. AtSeptember 30, 2021 , we had$949.9 million in outstanding commitments to originate loans. In addition to commitments to originate loans, we had$3.20 billion in unfunded home equity lines of credit to borrowers. CDs due within one year ofSeptember 30, 2021 totaled$3.51 billion , or 39.1% of total deposits. If these deposits do not remain with us, we will be required to seek other sources of funds, including loan sales, sales of investment securities, other deposit products, including new CDs, brokered CDs, FHLB advances, borrowings from the FRB-Cleveland Discount Window or other collateralized borrowings. Depending on market conditions, we may be required to pay higher rates on such deposits or other borrowings than we currently pay on the CDs due on or beforeSeptember 30, 2022 . We believe, however, based on past experience, that a significant portion of such deposits will remain with us. Generally, we have the ability to attract and retain deposits by adjusting the interest rates offered. Our primary investing activities are originating residential mortgage loans, home equity loans and lines of credit and purchasing investments. During the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 , we originated$3.63 billion of residential mortgage loans, and$1.74 billion of commitments for home equity loans and lines of credit, while during the year endedSeptember 30, 2020 , we originated$3.08 billion of residential mortgage loans and$1.32 billion of commitments for home equity loans and lines of credit. We purchased$297.5 million of securities during the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 , and$171.5 million during the year endedSeptember 30, 2020 . Also, during the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 , we purchased long-term, fixed-rate first mortgage loans that had a remaining balance of$43.0 million atSeptember 30, 2021 . Financing activities consist primarily of changes in deposit accounts, changes in the balances of principal and interest owed on loans serviced for others, FHLB advances, including any collateral requirements related to interest rate swap agreements and borrowings from the FRB-Cleveland Discount Window. We experienced a net decrease in total deposits of$231.9 million during the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 , which reflected the active management of the offered rates on maturing CDs compared to a net increase of$459.2 million during the year endedSeptember 30, 2020 . Deposit flows are affected by the overall level of interest rates, the interest rates and products offered by us and our local competitors, and by other factors. During the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 , there was a$61.9 million decrease in the balance of brokered CDs (exclusive of acquisition costs and subsequent amortization), which had a balance of$492.0 million atSeptember 30, 2021 . AtSeptember 30, 2020 the balance of brokered CDs was$553.9 million . Principal and interest owed on loans serviced for others experienced a net decrease of$4.4 million to$41.5 million during the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 compared to a net increase of$13.0 million to$45.9 million during the year endedSeptember 30, 2020 . During the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 we decreased our advances from the FHLB ofCincinnati by$429.9 million to utilize proceeds from loans sales, while managing future interest costs and the funding of new loan originations and our capital initiatives, and actively manage our 71 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Table of Contents liquidity ratio. During the year endedSeptember 30, 2020 , our advances from the FHLB ofCincinnati decreased by$381.2 million . InMarch 2021 , we received a second consecutive "Needs to Improve" rating on our Community Reinvestment Act (CRA) examination covering the period endingDecember 31, 2019 . The FHFA practice is to place member institutions in this situation on restriction. When this restriction is established, we will not have access to FHLB long-term advances (maturities greater than one year) until our rating improves. However, we have not received notice of this restriction as ofNovember 24, 2021 . Existing advances and future advances with less than a one year term, including 90 day advances used to facilitate longer term interest rate swap agreements, will not be affected. We expect no impact to our ability to access funding. Liquidity management is both a daily and long-term function of business management. If we require funds beyond our ability to generate them internally, borrowing agreements exist with the FHLB ofCincinnati and the FRB-Cleveland Discount Window, each of which provides an additional source of funds. Also, in evaluating funding alternatives, we may participate in the brokered CD market. AtSeptember 30, 2021 we had$3.09 billion of FHLB ofCincinnati advances and no outstanding borrowings from the FRB-Cleveland Discount Window. Additionally, atSeptember 30, 2021 , we had$492.0 million of brokered CDs. During the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 , we had average outstanding advances from the FHLB ofCincinnati of$3.30 billion as compared to average outstanding advances of$3.79 billion during the year endedSeptember 30, 2020 . Refer to the Extending the Duration of Funding Sources section of the Overview and the General section of Item 7A. Quantitative and Qualitative Disclosures About Market Risk for further discussion. AtSeptember 30, 2021 , we had the ability to borrow a maximum of$7.43 billion from the FHLB ofCincinnati and$245.7 million from the FRB-Cleveland Discount Window. From the perspective of collateral value securing FHLB ofCincinnati advances, our capacity limit for additional borrowings beyond the outstanding balance atSeptember 30, 2021 was$4.34 billion , subject to satisfaction of the FHLB ofCincinnati common stock ownership requirement. The Association and the Company are subject to various regulatory capital requirements, including a risk-based capital measure. The Basel III capital framework forU.S. banking organizations ("Basel III Rules") includes both a revised definition of capital and guidelines for calculating risk-weighted assets by assigning balance sheet assets and off-balance sheet items to broad risk categories. InApril 2020 , the Association adopted the Simplifications to the Capital Rule ("Rule") which simplified certain aspects of the capital rule under Basel III. The impact of the Rule was not material to the Association's regulatory ratios. In 2019, a final rule adopted by the federal banking agencies provided banking organizations with the option to phase in, over a three-year period, the adverse day-one regulatory capital effects of the adoption of the CECL accounting standard. In 2020, as part of its response to the impact of COVID-19,U.S. federal banking regulatory agencies issued a final rule which provides banking organizations that implement CECL during the 2020 calendar year the option to delay for two years an estimate of CECL's effect on regulatory capital, relative to the incurred loss methodology's effect on regulatory capital, followed by a three-year transition period, which the Association and Company have adopted. During the two-year delay, the Association and Company will add back to common equity tier 1 capital ("CET1"), 100% of the initial adoption impact of CECL plus 25% of the cumulative quarterly changes in the allowance for credit losses. After two years the quarterly transitional amounts along with the initial adoption impact of CECL will be phased out of CET1 capital over the three-year period. The Association is subject to the "capital conservation buffer" requirement level of 2.5%. The requirement limits capital distributions and certain discretionary bonus payments to management if the institution does not hold a "capital conservation buffer" in addition to the minimum capital requirements. AtSeptember 30, 2021 , the Association exceeded the regulatory requirement for the "capital conservation buffer". As ofSeptember 30, 2021 , the Association exceeded all regulatory capital requirements to be considered "Well Capitalized". In addition to the operational liquidity considerations described above, which are primarily those of the Association, the Company, as a separate legal entity, also monitors and manages its own, parent company-only liquidity, which provides the source of funds necessary to support all of the parent company's stand-alone operations, including its capital distribution strategies which encompass its share repurchase and dividend payment programs. The Company's primary source of liquidity is dividends received from the Association. The amount of dividends that the Association may declare and pay to the Company in any calendar year, without the receipt of prior approval from the OCC but with prior notice to the FRB-Cleveland, cannot exceed net income for the current calendar year-to-date period plus retained net income (as defined) for the preceding two calendar years, reduced by prior dividend payments made during those periods. InDecember 2020 , the Company received a$55.0 million cash dividend from the Association. Because of its intercompany nature, this dividend payment had no impact on the Company's capital ratios or its consolidated statement of condition but reduced the Association's reported capital ratios. AtSeptember 30, 2021 , the Company had, in the form of cash and a demand loan from the Association,$190.4 million of funds readily available to support its stand-alone operations. 72
————————————————– ——————————
Table of Contents The Company's eighth stock repurchase program, which authorized the repurchase of up to 10,000,000 shares of the Company's outstanding common stock was approved by the Board of Directors onOctober 27, 2016 and repurchases began onJanuary 6, 2017 . There were 4,108,921 shares repurchased under that program between its start date andSeptember 30, 2021 . During the year endedSeptember 30, 2021 , the Company did not repurchase any of its common stock. The share repurchase plan had been suspended as part of the response to COVID-19, but was reinstated inFebruary 2021 . However, the Company continues to place more emphasis on dividends in its evaluation of capital deployment. OnJuly 13, 2021 , Third Federal Savings, MHC received the approval of its members with respect to the waiver of dividends, and subsequently received the non-objection of the FRB-Cleveland, to waive receipt of dividends on the Company's common stock the MHC owns up to a total of$1.13 per share, to be declared on the Company's common stock during the 12 months subsequent to the members' approval (i.e., throughJuly 13, 2022 ). The members approved the waiver by casting 60% of the eligible votes, with 97% of the votes cast, or 59% of the total eligible votes, voting in favor of the waiver. Third Federal Savings, MHC is the 81% majority shareholder of the Company and waived its right to receive a$0.2825 per share dividend payment onSeptember 21, 2021 . OnJuly 14, 2020 , Third Federal Savings, MHC received the approval of its members with respect to the waiver of dividends, and subsequently received the non-objection of the FRB-Cleveland, to waive receipt of dividends on the Company's common stock the MHC owns up to a total of$1.12 per share, to be declared on the Company's common stock during the 12 months subsequent to the members' approval (i.e., throughJuly 14, 2021 ). The members approved the waiver by casting 63% of the eligible votes, with 97% of the votes cast, or 61% of the total eligible votes, voting in favor of the waiver. Third Federal Savings, MHC waived its right to receive a$0.28 per share dividend payment onSeptember 23, 2020 ,December 15, 2020 ,March 23, 2021 andJune 22, 2021 . The payment of dividends, support of asset growth and strategic stock repurchases are planned to continue in the future as the focus for future capital deployment activities. Impact of Inflation and Changing Prices Our consolidated financial statements and related notes have been prepared in accordance with GAAP. GAAP generally requires the measurement of financial position and operating results in terms of historical dollars without consideration for changes in the relative purchasing power of money over time due to inflation. The impact of inflation is reflected in the increased cost of our operations. Unlike industrial companies, our assets and liabilities are primarily monetary in nature. As a result, changes in market interest rates have a greater impact on performance than the effects of inflation. Recent Accounting Pronouncements Refer to Note 20. RECENT ACCOUNTING PRONOUNCEMENTS of the NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS for pending and adopted accounting guidance.
© Edgar online, source